fracas


My (not so) teensy quibble with Debra Messing

In her LA Times article, Veronique de Turenne took issue with a comment made by Debra Messing in their calendar section interview. Messing, explaining the conditions she’d set for her return to The Starter Wife, said this:

There’s no other job on earth where you’re asked to sign on for six years before you even know what the experience is going to be.

And quite rightfully so, de Turenne pointed out that the men and women (and their families) pictured in the photo she provided, have certainly done no less when they signed up to serve in the military.

I agree, de Turenne’s point is worthy and I say bravo to her for making it.

My quibble, though, is that de Turenne didn’t go far enough.

I can think of another job where you’re asked to sign up for much more than six years and you have no idea what the experience will be.

Debra Messing PhotoIt’s called Parenthood.

Without dispute, as a species, we would not exist were people not willing to sign up for this job, yet… no matter how many books you read in preparation, no matter how much well meaning advice from others you try incorporate into the job once you’ve accepted it, there is still no way to fully know what the job as it pertains to you will involve.

And yet many of us do it anyway.

For life.

Six years is but a sneeze in the grand scheme.

It’s not that she shouldn’t have “requests” before signing on to stay with the show; indeed, some of her requests are related to the fact she is a parent. I just happen to think as a parent herself, Messing should know that in fact, signing on for six years to do a show she will be paid handsomely for, provide her with the exposure and future offers to continue a career that affords her a lifestyle many would (and do) wish for, is hardly on par with the hardships of those who sign on to serve in the military, or who sign on to parent children who may end up being a thousandfold the committment ever imagined.

So, umm… Debra?

There’s no other job on earth?

Than acting?

You must not just be a starter wife… you must be a starter mom too!

Have you another good example? Post it in the comments, or write your own post with a link back here.


3 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Well you certainly took her to task! Just bent her over and gave her a good verbal spanking!

Comment by BILL

You are comparing apples to oranges. Parenthood, the military and TV are not comparable by any means. When you take on Parenthood you know it’s for a lifetime…well hopefully, and the military sure, but TV is fickle not forever. Six years in TV is nothing these days in six years you could be invested in something that could ruin your career while giving up other amazing opportunities offered to you. I have gone on and changed careers that were a mistake immediately. Thank goodness I got the chance to get out while I could and recoup my losses. Debra is a fine actress and should be able to make choices for her present and future.

Comment by Karen Belanger

LOL Bill, but as a parent… I haven’t spanked anyone for a very long time. I find withdrawing priviledges works better, and you know… spanking the teens is just physically challenging anyway.

Karen – Indeed, people know they sign up for parenting forever, but they rarely understand what it really means. No one ever brings a baby into the world expecting to raise a child with a disability or a mental illness, or just one who makes a poor choice as a teen and ends up bedridden and needing 24/7 care, etc. but these things happen. So my point was, that Messing was foolish to state:

“I can think of another job where you’re asked to sign up for much more than six years and you have no idea what the experience will be.”

Your statement that:

“in six years you could be invested in something that could ruin your career while giving up other amazing opportunities offered to you”

is exactly my point about parenthood and the military, and many other jobs. As a parent, no one thinks they signed up for something that might mean they have no choice but give up any future plans they had for themselves… but sometimes the things you didn’t know about parenting happen to you and you lose the chance to take those other wonderful opportunities.

Your comment actually helped make my point. Messing’s comment was poorly thought out and I’d like to think if she was able to say it over, she’d say it differently. The way it was said, kind of makes her appear to be just another vacuous actress who thinks acting is tougher than anything else. It may be a tough profession, but compared to the examples made by de Turenne and myself, it pales in comparison and is definitely not apples and oranges.

Comment by fracas




Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>